
By Joanna Orland
SPOILER WARNING: This article contains spoilers for ‘The Traitors UK’ Season 4 and ‘The Celebrity Traitors UK’ Season 1.
The Traitors UK Season 4 has created a template on how to play the game. By forming an alliance with each other, traitors Stephen Libby and Rachel Duffy were always a step ahead of the faithfuls and other traitors. By sticking together, getting rid of the other two traitors and not recruiting another, they removed the stress of worrying about traitor-on-traitor action, and focused solely on taking down the faithfuls.
By having each others’ backs, Stephen and Rachel were able to make bolder choices, get out of many close calls, and use their voting power in their favour. It also became a more positive, less villainous, and more forgiving outcome when two traitors won the season. This is how the game should be played going forward.
Aligned Traitors Can Focus on Eliminating Faithfuls
Because Stephen and Rachel were respectfully open and honest with each other about their gameplay, it reduced the stress that traitors normally feel about turning on each other. This stress reduction helped them centre and focus on their gameplay, to take out the faithfuls one by one.
Because they had less to worry about amongst each other, they were able to make bolder choices and work together to get out of close calls. Without Rachel’s support, Stephen would have struggled to make it to the finale — Jessie Stride clocked Stephen as a traitor early on, and he was under a lot of pressure to prove himself otherwise. As he and Rachel united to get rid of their fellow traitor Fiona Hughes, she took the fall for being the traitor in the room for Ross Garshong’s elimination, and Stephen was able to temporarily escape Jessie’s targeting.
By boldly murdering Jessie immediately after she accused him again, Stephen had Rachel’s support in talking his way out of a suspicious situation. Rachel was always key in shifting the focus and conversation away from Stephen, steering the votes away from him at the roundtable. She would subtly keep him in the mix as one of her suspects, as she said she would do to avoid suspicion, but was always up front with him about her motives.
By working together, Stephen and Rachel used their combined voting power in their favour. Much as Rachel defended Stephen from suspicion early on, Stephen did the same for Rachel when it came to the end game. When faithful eyes finally turned to Rachel, had Stephen not aligned his votes with hers, she wouldn’t have made it. Then, when Faraaz Noor explicitly approached Jack Butler wanting to be the only two players remaining, Stephen and Rachel’s planning and commitment took care of that.
In the finale, Stephen and Rachel were able to divide and conquer to win the game. As Faraaz wanted to remove Jade Scott, Rachel, and Stephen to finish the game solely with Jack, the traitors’ votes needed to be in sync. Rachel worked on manipulating Faraaz while Stephen focused on Jack. Jade was the first to get voted out, and easily so since she was under suspicion from day one. Next, Rachel had to convince Faraaz to vote for Stephen, while Stephen had to ensure Jack kept his vote for Rachel, so they could then team up to remove Faraaz and get the majority vote. It was a genius play, as Stephen looked guilty by switching his first vote to Jade, it was fresh in Faraaz’s mind and used as ammunition. Faraaz believed Rachel would also vote for Stephen, so kept his vote for the majority. Meanwhile, Stephen kept his friend Jack close to him to ensure that Rachel would still be getting his vote first. After Faraaz and Jack were manipulated to split the vote, it was an easy win for a traitor.
Traitors Being Faithful to Each Other Makes for a More Positive Outcome
An alliance of traitors made for a more positive, less villainous, and less toxic season. Because of the traitors’ alliance, both Rachel and Stephen made it to the finale together — arguably, neither would have if they hadn’t had each other’s backs throughout. At this point, Stephen had the opportunity to turn on Rachel with Jack’s vote, and take the win for himself. As he opted not to betray her, he kept his morals intact, and played the game in the most dignified way a traitor could — by remaining faithful to his fellow traitor.
As the two traitors remained faithful to each other until the very end, it made for a more forgiving win. As fun as it is to watch a traitor win over faithfuls, the friendship betrayals can leave a bad taste in the mouth with how it plays out (see Season 2). But because Stephen and Rachel always had each other’s backs, their betrayal of their other faithfuls and friends didn’t hit as hard. It was more in the spirit of the game rather than personal manipulation, and leaning on each other for support portrayed a more positive message than usual. The show has felt rather nasty in past seasons (see Season 3), but finally as the traitors played with dignity and reliability, it felt more like a fun game rather than a mean-spirited social experiment.
‘The Celebrity Traitors UK’ Also Had a Successful Traitors Alliance
The Celebrity Traitors UK Season 1 reaffirms that a pair of traitors works better than every-traitor-for-themself. Cat Burns and Alan Carr, even Jonathan Ross to an extent, remained aligned from the start, resulting in another win for the traitors. Without Alan and Cat being aligned, neither was as likely to have made it to the final. Alan clearly would’ve loved to have won alongside Cat, but either way, he never wavered in his support for her.
While Alan ultimately was unable to save Cat, he still played the best game he could while remaining faithful to her. With his honest and reliable gameplay as far as Cat was concerned, alongside his emotional breakdown about the difficulty of being a traitor, he won over the hearts of the general public and fellow players. This resulted in one of the best and most endearing seasons of The Traitors.
With the success story of Alan Carr, and to a greater extent the successful dual win of Stephen Libby and Rachel Duffy, The Traitors has demonstrated that the game is better played in pairs. Aligning with a fellow traitor allows for bolder moves, voting power, and a chance to divide and conquer, all while keeping some sort of moral code that otherwise lacks in the wider gameplay. When traitors remain faithful to each other, the outcome is greater for them and the audience.
–
The Traitors UK is available on Peacock
