
By Joanna Orland
SPOILER WARNING: This article contains spoilers for ‘RuPaul’s Drag Race All Stars’ Season 10
As of late, the RuPaul’s Drag Race franchise has been floundering, particularly in their All Stars seasons. Drag Race All Stars Seasons 8 and 9 are barely watchable, so a big change was needed for Season 10. It was very promising when the show came back strong with a new tournament format, yet the series falls into old habits with favoured judging, a predictable winner, and worst of all, it’s still rewarding bad behaviour.
The new format injects a bit of life into the tired All Stars setup, promising a more sport-like competition with a tournament. Divided into three brackets, six queens compete in each, with the top three per bracket moving forward to the semi-final. By having queens feature in fewer episodes this season, Drag Race is able to bring back some heavy-hitters and fan-favourites. If only it were a fair competition.
The Tournament of All Stars Is the Right Idea, Wrong Execution
Drag Race All Stars inarguably needed to do something different to keep its audience invested. Past attempts at changing things up were a huge success, such as the All Stars Season 7 “All Winners Season,” which saw Jinkx Monsoon win the “Queen of All Queens” title. Since then, the quality has hugely dipped with an unwatchable Season 8 that boasts a weak line-up, and has fan-favourite Heidi N Closet dramatically quit before her time. Season 9 is hardly much better, even with a stronger lineup of queens, everything about it feels off. Season 10’s tournament format is a more-than-welcome change at this point.
While a new format is most definitely the right approach to the latest season of All Stars, it should’ve been fine tuned to play out better. Top queens only need to be in six episodes in total before a winner is chosen. This means we hardly get to spend time with the favoured queens, and the season is over in a flash. While this is a good way to keep things fresh and showcase more All Star queens than usual, it causes the competition to feel superficial and rushed, with the winner hardly putting in much effort before snatching the crown.
Because there are three brackets of three episodes each, it also means that the early-bracket queens are off-screen for way too long before coming back in the semi-final. Half of the show passes before they return! Especially with a stacked first bracket, the new format causes some pacing problems for the season.
Not All Brackets Are Created Equal
Another problem for the season is the handful of queens who have been on multiple seasons of All Stars. They have a competitive advantage over the others, but also have less good will from fans since they’ve had multiple seasons to showcase their talents — some of it is getting a bit tired. While it’s great to see Aja come back with a new perspective, we’ve seen it all before with Ginger Minj and Jorgeous. Returning queens should have all been pitted against each other in the same bracket, giving the other queens more of a fair chance at the crown. This would also spare the audience from getting bored of the returning queens’ talents.
Even though the returning queens feature across multiple brackets, the brackets are not laid out evenly in talent, fan-favourites, judging, or tone. Bracket 1 is so much fun, showcasing mostly positive energy, and some beloved queens like Bosco, Aja, and the surprise hit of the season — Irene the Alien. Straight out of the gate, the reviews were raving and it felt like Drag Race All Stars had finally returned to form. Irene and Bosco were the clear frontrunners of their bracket, and the vibe is friendly, fun, and an appreciation of the art of drag.
Following such a positive and fun bracket, Bracket 2 lands like deadweight, bringing down the tone, and souring the vibe. While talented queens are featured and redemption arcs are had (Tina Burner), Mistress Isabelle Brooks taints it so much with bullying, games, and insecurity — all of a sudden, what was a loving showcase of drag becomes a mean-spirited game that only some people want to play. Tina Burner, Nicole Paige Brooks, and Kerri Colby really deserve better. Watching malicious games beat out genuine talent rightfully leaves a bad taste in the audience’s mouth.
Bracket 3 faces a big challenge in overcoming the nasty vibes from Bracket 2, and also the judges’ overt favouritism. Even though there is tension between some of the queens, like Daya Betty and Alyssa Hunter, the general chemistry between this cohort is on point and a far better mesh than the previous bracket. The issue with this bracket is the skewed judging, which unfairly favours Ginger Minj.
Now, Ginger is a talented queen, no one is saying otherwise — but, after multiple appearances on Drag Race, with this being her third on All Stars and fourth overall, she’s bringing nothing new to the competition. Sure, there are some challenges and lip syncs she deservedly wins, but the clean sweep she has throughout the competition is biased and set up to put her at the top of the competition. While Ginger may have perhaps rightfully made it to the final, it is at the expense of other queens who deserve a fairer shot. In particular, Denali is obviously given the short end of the stick and in no way should’ve been shut out from the semi-final. Her omission has disappointed many Drag Race fans, but also has turned many against Ginger, merely for the fact that she is treated with favour.
And The Crown Unsurprisingly Goes To…
The judge’s favouritism leads to a very predictable finale, with Jorgeous and Ginger Minj competing in the final lip sync for the crown. Not to fault their talent or determination in taking the top two spots, but because of the judging and framing this entire season, it is an uncompelling, underwhelming top two and winner. There was literally no other way this finale would turn out, which makes it boring and feel rigged. Based on their reactions and comments, even the other competing queens see this one coming.
The two queens who come in behind Jorgeous and Ginger — Bosco and Lydia B Kollins — should’ve been the top two. Either would’ve been a worthy winner, a more well-rounded choice, and feel like a more honest result. By it being so predictably Ginger as the winner, it only adds fuel to the fire of the favouritism accusations, creating a bigger fan backlash to the series, hurting future seasons of the show. If the competition doesn’t feel honest or real, it becomes more difficult to keep being invested in the series.
In some ways, Drag Race All Stars 10 has exactly delivered on its promise — that Ginger Minj would be crowned the winner, and Jorgeous would be runner-up. Yet, the promise of All Stars 10 was bigger and better than that from the start, with an exciting new format and a fantastic lineup to boot. The show can’t help but get in its own way even when it tries hard to do what it thinks the audience wants. But, the audience doesn’t want favouritism, nastiness, or predictability. While a tournament is a good start, All Stars Season 11 will need an even bigger shakeup if it wants to reinvigorate the franchise.
–
RuPaul’s Drag Race All Stars Season 10 is available on Paramount+
